The following is an essay I wrote when I was in graduate school, some two years before I came under grace. I was still living like a rebellious younger brother at the time and I was lead by the Spirit to re-read this essay a couple of days ago. It floored me at how directly Papa was speaking to me through my writing in revealing himself even though I was doing everything I could to ignore His voice. The essay is rather long and academic, but take a gander:
Matt Monk
From Stagnation to Revelation: Identifying the Narrator of Paradise Lost
The narrative style of Paradise Lost has long been a subject of much discussion among critics. In many valiant attempts to locate the identity of the narrator, no general consensus has been reached. In the following essay, I propose to uncover the identity of the narrator of Paradise Lost. Through an Areopagitican reading of the poem, I compare the narrator to John, the author of the Book of Revelation, and propose that the narrator is in exile, engaged in an intense process of reinterpreting his/her understanding of all things religious and spiritual, the results of which are the narrator’s writing of the poem as an attempt to reconcile his/herself to the world of men and return from exile.
In the first section of the essay, I examine the narrator’s method as necessary groundwork to uncover the identity of the narrator. The second section adopts Areopagitica as a frame for reading Paradise Lost. By doing so, I argue that the narrator’s motive can be established. In the final section, I address in detail the identity of the narrator.
I. The Narrator’s Method
In order to uncover the narrator’s identity, the method which the narrator employs throughout Paradise Lost to tell his/her tale must be established. The opening of the poem begins with the narrator’s invocation to the muse which issues forth the subject to be discussed throughout:
Of Man’s First Disobedience, and the Fruit
Of that Forbidden Tree, whose mortal taste
Brought Death into the World, and all our woe,
With loss of Eden, till one greater man
Restore us, and regain the blissful Seat,
Sing Heavenly muse (1:1-6)
These opening lines introduce that a discussion of the fall of man will comprise the content of the work. The repetition of the preposition “Of” in the first two lines suggests containment. It is an equivocation that requires an assumption. For instance, if X is of Y then it can be safely assumed that X is somehow contained by or within Y. Thus “Man’s First Disobedience...” will form the contents of the tale that the narrator feels compelled to recount with the help of his/her “Heavenly Muse.”
By beginning with the invocation to the muse, the narrator lulls the audience into the mimicry of epic structure, but as Jane Melbourne argues, “the personality and role...are quite different of a traditional epic narrator” (“The Narrator” 149). The manner in which the narrator poses the opening lends the audience to lean in the direction that an epic is exactly what is going to be told. The narrator adopts the form of the epic to give the audience a feeling of familiarity within a work that admittedly becomes something entirely different. A few lines later still in the invocation, the narrator pleads to his/her muse and relates his/her intent:
Invoke thy aid to my adventurous Song,
That with no middle flight intends to soar
Above the Aonian Mount, while it pursues
Things unattempted yet in prose or rhyme. (1:12-16)
The usage of the phrase “Things unattempted” signposts the idea that the poem is going to try to accomplish something that has not been done before. This relates back to the idea that “Of” signifies containment. In the sense that the structure of the work is “Of” epic structure, the “adventurous Song” and “Things unattempted” suggest that the work is really something other than an epic.
The subjects introduced at the beginning of the invocation must also be regarded in this context. Just as the poem is “Of” epic structure but yet asserts itself to be something else, the subject of the poem is “Of Man’s First Disobedience,” but is about something else entirely. The idea of “till one greater man / Restore us” moves beyond the “Of” that relates only to what the poem contains, and expresses what the contents really are supposed to be about. In this case, the content in regards to plot, rising/falling action, and other general terms that describe the composition of a story do not reveal anything about what the story means and why the narrator is telling it. Yann Martel cogently explains this concept in the introduction to Life of Pi, “This is not illogical if you realize...that a novel set in Portugal in 1939 may have very little to do with Portugal in 1939” (VII). It would be expected that by using the biblical story of Adam and Eve that the same lessons contained in the biblical account will be imparted. The audience can make this assumption, but doing so dismisses the question of motivation. The biblical account of The Fall has already been written and is already well known. So why is it of any significance that the narrator is retelling the story? In this sense it is necessary to conclude that there are other layers of significance that are going to be constantly emerging. So opening the poem with “Of the Man’s First Disobedience” does not necessarily mean that The Fall of Man is going to be what the story is about.
The narrator tells the audience from the very first lines of the work, though subtly, that he/she is only using the story of the fall of Man as a framing device by which he/she can explore the essential questions of his/her intention, hence “Things unattempted yet in prose or rhyme.” At first, the narrator’s true concern seems a tad nebulous. The familiarity of the traditional epic opening and the context of a well-known story of both Christian and Judaic background forces the audience to accept the terms presented, though the terms are only partially revealed. In “Paradise Lost as a republican ‘tractus theologico-politicus’”, Armand Himy relates likewise:
If accommodation serves as a kind of link between heaven and earth, indirection makes flexibility the rule when theology and literature, poetic and political style, are all involved at once. Milton’s language is involuted...of the process of building language into language so as to create levels of meaning...(Milton and Republicanism 119)
Both the usage of “Of” and the employment of epic structure from the outset serve as framing devices that become further realized later in the work. The “accommodation” that Himy mentions refers to the ability of the narrator to provide familiar structuring devices that welcome the audience into the work but expand gradually the different layers of meaning as the work progresses towards the end. It is through this method that the narrator is about to sing an “adventurous Song” that employs “Things unattempted yet in prose or rhyme.” By introducing the thematic and essential questions of the work through a voice echoing that of a traditional epic and relating the themes within a story that a large majority of the world already knows, the narrator can now coil layers of meaning into the work and allow the audience to unravel the multiple significances piece by piece as the narrative continues.
As the narrative unfolds, the layers begin to emerge. Even early in Book I, the narrator introduces allusions to deities and holy places belonging to other religious and mythological traditions:
By younger Saturn, he from mightier Jove
His own and Rhea’s Son like measure found;
So Jove usurping reign’d : these first in Crete
And Ida known, thence on the Snowy top
Of cold Olympus rul’d the middle Air (1:512-16)
The passage continues, listing many other allusions as well, and the narrator assumes that the audience will accept his/her terms by employing the use of these allusions. Indeed already at this point, the readers have been blasted by so many obscure biblical allusions that the above references may be either skimmed over as unimportant or deemed to be in perfect harmony with the rest of the piece. The misplacement and disjunction that occurs is that narrator now employs a framework that is not fully Christian in order to relate the telling of a traditional Christian tale, thus further reemphasizing the distinction between “Of” and about.
The narration progresses in this manner even further by the beginning of Book III. Here, the narrator is not so timid as he/she splashes references that are outside the reading of the Christian cannon, and also boldly steers away from any Christian allusion in the invocation. This suggests that the narrator is praying to a non-Christian muse, or that the muses exist in every part as long as they are sought, “Yet not the more / Cease I to wander where the muses haunt” (3:26-7). A striking distinction is asserted within these lines. If the narrator were solely concerned with counting a good Christian tale that contained good Christian morals, then the Holy Spirit would be the voice invoked. The invocation of Book III is notably devoid of any Christian allusions other than “God” which is also a name employed for deity outside of Christianity. “Muse” is decidedly a Greek term and not one that can be easily placed in any Christian context, yet here the narrator uses it. “Muse”, in relation to the spirit being invoked, is juxtaposed with the idea of a Christian god, and suggests that “God” in this sense may not be the Christian god the audience expects. At this juncture, the audience should call into memory the Book I invocation, which also employs the use of the term “muse” and leaves “Holy Spirit” absent. Book I’s invocation differs and is seemingly more deceptive than Book III’s because contained with Book I there are many other Christian allusions. The framework of a traditionally Christian tale, combined with multiple Christian allusions distracts the reader from the weirdness of adopting the use of the term “muse” in this context. In Book III, the narrator furthers his/her equivocation of Christianity with other religions:
So were I equall’d with them in renown
Blind Thamyris and Blind Maenides,
And Tiresias and Phineus Prophets old.
Then feed on thoughts, that voluntary move
Harmonious numbers (3:33-7).
The notable importance of the references that name the “Prophets old” are that none of the people listed are Christian prophets. If the narrator wishes to be, “equall’d with them in renown”, then it follows that the narrator aspires to prophesy in the same manner, which is to prophesy through the power of a non-Christian god.
Recent criticism has paid much attention to the details that can elucidate the identification of the narrator. John Guillory asserts Paradise Lost is a “cryptic self-portrait” not of the narrator but of Milton (Labriola 13). An interpretation such as Guillory’s argues that the importance of the allusions to non-Christian prophets relates to shared physical blindness the prophets had with Milton at the time he was writing Paradise Lost, his insertion of the blind prophets is Milton’s method of announcing himself as the narrator. This line of thinking dismisses the distinction that it is possible that Milton could be a different person than the narrator. Joseph Wittreich sheds some light on this idea in his article, “Reading Milton: The Death (And Survival of the Author”, suggesting that the characters in Paradise Lost act completely according to their own logic, operating completely outside of the identity of the author (Labriola 18). Wittreich’s idea may unblur the identity of the narrator if the narrator is considered a character just as Raphael and Adam are characters. In relation to Wittreich’s remarks, the above suggests that the blindness of the prophets is only significant when considering the narrator. In this regard, Milton’s physical handicap has little to do with the identity of the narrator, and most probably the blindness of the prophets in some way forms a metaphorical significance to the narrator rather than a physical one. Even though the narrator has framed his/her work structurally as traditional epic that contains a traditional biblical tale, the allusion to non-Christian prophets emphasizes the narrator’s desire to prophesy in the same manner. To prophesy is to invoke the muse, or to see as God sees. But if the allusions are not Christian, then the narrator requests the divine help from a non-Christian deity. This has several implications, one may be that the narrator distrusts the Christian God, another may be that the narrator believes the forces of differing deities can aid him/her, and the last may be that the narrator thinks that all deities, in whatever manner they may be named, reference the same all-abiding force. Whichever the case, the Book III provides further evidence that the narrator’s use of epic strategies and the framework of a well-known biblical story serve as the narrator’s “Portugal”, but indeed the narrator’s tale may be about something else entirely. As mentioned earlier, the poem progresses and the narrator’s purpose becomes clearer. The invocation to Book VII adds flesh to the vague skeleton Books I and III have produced.
The proem to Book VII (and Book IX also) continue the mixing of both Christian and Greek allusion, but differs in that it provides a clear reasoning as to why the allusions are being mixed. Unlike the previous invocations that only name allusions and leave the audience with ambivalent notions about what is purposed, Book VII states outright what the purpose is, thereby providing a context by which the invocations to Books I and III can be interpreted. The narrator issues his/her desires more concretely:
The meaning, not the Name I call: for thou
Nor of the Muses nine, nor on the top
Of old Olympus dwell’st, but Heavn’ly born,
Before the Hills appear’d or Fountain flow’d,
Thou with Eternal Wisdom didst converse (7:5-9)
The terms that the narrator has set, are a search for the essence of what “God” in all of its many forms and names may mean, hence, “The meaning, not the Name I call”. Peter C. Herman comments, “Milton uses ‘or’ to conflate difference, he also uses “or” to provide a choice between different items without indicating a preference” (Destabilizing 45). As Herman suggests, the choice to be non-preferential presents a similar method in not seeking “the Name.” This being the case, the narrator has called upon many different names in an attempt to seek out the true nature of deity. The structure of the narrative reflects this. Just as the narrator may employ epic form to tell a story that surprisingly veers away from epic themes and use the context of a biblical story to express many non-Christian ideals, he/she may invoke the names of many different gods and goddesses just as long as he/she can be in touch with the essence of something truly divine. The method of the narrator then is the compilation of many different sources and layers, the mixing of which cannot be named.
II. Confessions of Narrative Style
By examining the method of the narrator in the first section, I suggest that this will lay the groundwork for the identity of the narrator to be uncovered. Several major identifying factors can be gleaned from the narrative context of the poem. In this section I assert that by using Areopagitica to interpret the narration in Paradise Lost, the purpose behind the narrator’s method can be established.
The use of allusion that references various religious sects and historical circumstances throughout Paradise Lost suggests that the narrator is well learned across many different subjects. The use of epic structure along with all of the classical allusions argues that the narrator has had an intense classical education. The various Christian allusions and placement of the poem within the context of the Garden of Eden argues further that the narrator has been raised with some type of Christian background. Whether these assertions are correct or not, the narrator’s detailed knowledge suggests that he/she is someone who has read and attempted to focus their learning across a wide range of subjects. Admittedly seeking, “The meaning, not the Name”(7:5), the narrator’s interest in many different subjects and use of conflating different religious and mythological traditions to find the meaning that is being sought, relates to much of what is expressed in Areopagitica. As Milton comments in the prose piece:
Well knows he who uses to consider, that our faith and knowledge thrives by exercise, as well as our limbs and complexion. Truth is compared in scripture to a streaming fountain; if her waters flow not in perpetual progression, then sicken into a muddy pool of conformity and tradition. A man may be a heretic in the truth; and if he believe things only because his pastor says so, or the Assembly so determines, without knowing other reason, through his belief be true, yet the very truth he holds becomes his heresy.
Composed as an essay to counteract the licensing of books that was occurring in England during his time, Milton turns a secular problem into one that carries heavy religious and moral weight. His contention is that through the wide reading of books, and especially books that provide different interpretations of existence, a person learns to better exercise their faculties of reasoning and therefore has a better understanding of what is good and what is evil. The inclusion of religious ideals within the context of a secular problem in Areopagitica provides an example of the same mixing that the narrator of Paradise Lost does in both the structure and the inclusion of non-Christian allusions in the poem. The purpose seems clear that Milton’s techniques in Areopagitica relate to Peter C. Herman’s comments that, “Milton never believed that religion should be exempted from the exercise of human reason” (Destabilizing 114).
In the sense that both Areopagitica and Paradise Lost contain a mixing of ideas and contexts that generally aren’t mixed, both the poem and the prose piece serve as lenses by which to interpret one another. The assertion that:
A man may be a heretic in the truth; and if he believe things only because his pastor says so, or the Assembly so determines, without knowing other reason, through his belief be true, yet the very truth he holds becomes his heresy.
asserts the same idea with which the narrator of Paradise Lost is grappling. If indeed he/she is calling for, “The meaning, not the Name”, then he/she is urgently concerned with becoming a “heretic in the truth.” As mentioned earlier, the insertion of both Christian and non-Christian allusions within the framework of the traditionally Christian story of the Garden of Eden presents the narrator’s attempt at demonstrating that he/she is not a “heretic in the truth.” Searching for the “meaning” as opposed to simply following “the Name” implies that the narrator is searching out truth, or wandering. If the narrator eventually arrives at the same conclusion that his pastor or assembly does, then his/her search has proven profitable because, “our faith and knowledge thrives by exercise” and thus the understanding that has been reached is fuller due to the fact that it will have been established according to his/her own terms through his/her own searching. If an understanding different than that of what the “pastor” and “Assembly” believes is reached, then the one who has searched is not a heretic, but simply one who’s search has lead them to a different conclusion.
Milton continues in a similar manner concerning the ability to reach a different conclusion than a religious group or official. In speaking about truth he comments further in Areopagitica, “Yet is it not impossible that she may have mores shapes than one?” Milton refers to truth as “she” a personified feminine entity, which moves away from the traditional Christian notion that truth is the embodiment of the sexless Holy Spirit. The use of truth as feminine evokes the philosophies of both the classical Greeks and Romans, and also Gnostic religions that split with Christianity. Having, “more shapes than one” ties directly into what the narrator of Paradise Lost is attempting to express through adopting the use of mixed allusions and religious imagery. The narrator clearly, through the method detailed in Section I, would agree that truth can be found in many “shapes”. The narrator is thereby concerned with what the object represents rather than the object itself, in other words, “The meaning, not the Name I call.” The narrator, just as Milton, may find a different manner to call upon truth, but just because the manner and the method are different, does not mean that the truth itself is different.
In some ways the narrator’s choice to adopt the method I have detailed in Section I, relates to temptation. What is used to tempt the narrator could be anything, but in reference to the religious question that emerges from Paradise Lost, Matthew 4:4 serves to illustrate the nature of the type of temptation the narrator is concerned with, “It is written, ‘Man shall not live by bread alone, but by every word that proceeds from the mouth of God”. Milton focuses heavily on this biblical scene of the temptation of Christ in Paradise Regained. The dialogue between Satan and Jesus relates:
That out of these hard stones be made thee bread;
So shalt thou save thyself and us relieve
With Food, whereof we wretched seldom taste.
He ended and the Son of God replied.
Think’st thou such force in Bread? is it not written
For I discern thee other than thou seems’t
Man lives not by Bread only, but each Word
Proceeding from the mouth of God (1.343-50)
The emphasis placed on “every word proceeding from the mouth of God” quoted by Jesus here and in Matthew’s account expresses a similar concern as the narrator of Paradise Lost. To the narrator who seeks “The meaning, not the Name” and approaches it by issuing forth “Things unattempted yet in prose or rhyme”, Bread becomes “the Name” as it is the singular object that may cause a person not to continue seeking. In cross referencing Areopagitica, the Bread is precisely the belief in “things only because his pastor says so, or the Assembly so determines”. The temptation that is presented and that the narrator of Paradise Lost finds problematic, is the temptation to accept what is told without seeking or searching to discover whether out not it may be true. If what is asserted is assumed or concluded to be true, then the further temptation is to remain complacent and to cease striving for fuller understanding, as Milton relates further, “Truth is compared in scripture to a streaming fountain; if her waters flow not in perpetual progression, they sicken into a muddy pool of conformity and tradition”(Areopagitica 739).
The metaphor of Bread as cited above from Paradise Regained serves to relate a process of transition and transformation. By using this passage to interpret Paradise Lost, transformation and its relationship to the narrator can be established. After the occurrence of the fall, Book X notes, “In the sweat of thy Face thou shalt eat Bread”(205). In this context, Bread becomes a result, meaning that Man must do something in order to eat. Eve relates similarly:
Our task we choose, what wonder it so near
Looks intervene and smiles, or object new
Casual discourse draw on, which intermits
Our day’s work brought to little, though begun
Early, and th’ hour of Supper comes unearned (9:220-24).
Man/Womankind must earn its bread. As Jesus is tempted to turn stones into bread by Satan, Man/Womankind is tempted to take the bread that is given by a pastor, assembly or other church official. To partake of bread in this manner is nothing more than engaging in a “Casual discourse”. Bread as a metaphor for fruition, if it comes unearned is meaningless. If given through a process by which it was not earned or sought after, indeed may make a “heretic in the truth.” It is the narrator’s purpose, through the merging of Christian and non-Christian elements, to demonstrate that he/she has indeed earned his/her Bread.
But for the narrator, it seems that earning only Bread is not enough. The Bread must be earned, but once this is accomplished, the recipient must not remain complacent with simply having Bread. If Bread has to be earned, then “Man shall not live by bread alone, but by every word” implies that further searching and progression is the necessary duty required for Man/Womankind not to fall into this category. “By every word” then specifically addresses the problems that the licensing of books will cause, as argued in Areopagitica. Books are the physical apparati that contain words. If human kind indeed is supposed to live “By every word”, then it should engage in the practice of searching and reading widely, across disciplines and different religious ideas. This practice should provide the continuance of the process of transformation. The narrator of Paradise Lost requests, “Then feed on thoughts”(1.37), which can be produced through searching, experiencing, and reading widely. Transformation can only be made complete through a continued engagement with the process of searching.
The transformation that is sought involves the inner workings of the individual. Being that the narrator never gives a physical description of his/herself, the narrator’s method, focus, and purpose in relating transformation is one that includes material that is other than physical. The Book III invocation relates:
But cloud instead, and ever-during dark
Surrounds me, form the cheerful ways of men
Cut off, and for the Book of knowledge fair
Presented with a Universal blanc
Of Nature’s works to me expung’d and ras’d (3.45-8)
The narrator describes a separation from the physical world that is illumined and understood better through the separation. In relation, Bread then becomes a metaphor for the body which connects to the taking of the Lord’s supper as Christ tells his disciples in Matthew 26:26, “Jesus took bread, blessed and broke it, and gave it to the disciples and said, “Take, eat; this is My body: (NKJ). Thus in re-examining the lines from Book X, “In the sweat of thy Face thou shalt eat Bread” the idea of partaking only the Bread is self-consumptive. If Bread is the body and the Bread must be earned, to consume only Bread eventually means that the body will be completely consumed and thus becomes “a muddy pool of conformity and tradition”, that can no longer progress because it has disappeared and lacks the capacity to provide for itself. Either self-consumption is inevitable, or there must be a method of prevention or progression to move beyond. Christ further tells his disciples in Matthew 26:27-28, “Drink from it, all of you. For this is My blood” (NKJ). To partake in only the Bread is to deny the drinking of the blood. The blood then represents the part that sustains the body or the force that runs beneath preventing the body from atrophy. If the blood stops flowing, then the body will perish. Symbolically, the blood is the other part that must be engaged through searching to find new understanding or deepen the manner by which beliefs that are already established may be perceived. To “believe things only because his pastor says so, or the Assembly so determines” is to siphon the blood out of the body, drying out the ebbing waters of truth. The narrator’s purpose then becomes his or her attempt at developing and deepening further understanding.
III. Exiled and Transformed
In the first section of this essay I examined the method of the narrator which employs the apparatus of an epic that the framework of a biblical story, but whose real mode of operation is much different than epic and whose themes do not teach traditionally Christian ideals. In the second section, I examined Paradise Lost in the terms of Areopagitica, and argued that through this lens the narrator’s purpose argues that a wide exposure to books, ideas and experiences is the only manner in which someone can search for truth and increase their understanding. My final section uncovers the identity of the narrator.
The identity of the narrator of Paradise Lost, is presented simultaneously as certain and ambiguous. As mentioned in the first section, by simply considering the sheer volume of allusions and references that are piled and interwoven into Paradise Lost, it is easily deduced that the narrator must be a person who has been widely educated. Jane Melbourne makes the assertion that the narrator was a participant in the Fall, and since the Fall:
has an overwhelmingly important stake in the outcome of the action. He is, moreover, a character in this action. He knows what Galileo is up to, knows the trade routes, can speak of Mexico and Montezuma and El Dorado, knows the mythologies of several cultures—possesses, in short, the accumulation of human learning since the Fall (“The Narrator 157).
Melbourne continues in this manner to suggest that since Milton mimics some aspects of Epic style, that the narrator must be acting as the Chorus of Paradise Lost. She suggests further that because the narrator has been a participant, he (Melbourne also assumes the narrator’s sex resoundingly is male) “cannot be objective” (157). This lack of objectivism undermines the traditional role of the Chorus, but Melbourne’s equivocation fails to address what the Chorus’ purpose would be in telling the tale. The argument proposed by Melbourne places the narrator’s education as some type of divine knowledge that has been acquired as a result of the Fall. Melbourne does not address how the knowledge was gained, assuming that since the Fall occurred, the narrator must somehow just have the entire epic of human history swirling in his head. If the narrator has simply been given the information as some type of divine gift, indeed the information has not been processed, or the Bread has not been earned. Thus, to locate the narrator as the Chorus is to place him/her in the category of a “heretic in the truth” because the knowledge has simply been received and not searched out or questioned. In this sense, the narrator becomes an automaton who gives a dry and bitter retelling of the events he experienced.
Melbourne’s critique, though ambitious, fails to address several key questions. It is my assertion that locating the narrator as some type of divine other that is represented by the Chorus, dismisses the very human questioning that happens constantly within Paradise Lost and fallaciously does not consider that even from the introduction of the poem, the narrator calls to divine powers to help him/her tell the tale. This theory also dismisses the process of the narrator’s education and purpose behind writing. The “accumulation of all human learning since the Fall” has been acquired by the narrator through intense study not divine revelation. The narrator calls on the muse not for the revelation of worldly historical knowledge, but for aid in relating his/her knowledge into a coherent form. The invocation to Book I relates that:
What in me is dark
Illumine, what is low raise and support;
That to the highth of this great Argument
I may assert Eternal Providence,
And justify the ways of God to men (1:21-5)
The narrator very specifically describes, “What in me” meaning that there is something within the narrator that is “dark” and must be “illumined.” This suggests that the narrator is not a tabula raza to be imprinted by a divine revelation. Instead, the invoking of the muse becomes a method of further searching to attempt to reach understanding, not only for the narrator him/herself, but also so that he/she may “justify the ways of God to men.”
By highlighting the nature of the telling, the narrator identifies the poem as a state of transition. As mentioned in the second section, the idea of developing understanding is one that is transitory, but in “justify(ing) the ways of God to men”, the narrator attempts to provide and illustrate the process of transition. The process involves describing what is infinite through vehicles that are finite. In this regard, the narrator can much likened to John, the author of the Book of Revelation. John is called to relate a spiritual vision that has been passed to him, Revelation 1:1-2 relates:
The Revelation of Jesus Christ, which God gave Him to show His servants—things which must shortly take place. And He sent and signified it by His angel to His servant John, who bore witness to the word of God, and to the testimony of Jesus Christ, to all things that he saw. (NKJ)
The predicament of the narrator and John are similar in that they must describe and relate visions of the spiritual and infinite through mediums that are physical and finite. John approaches the manner by employing the use of symbolic systems to tell his tale, applying many Old and New Testament allusions to try to provide a context that his readers can identify with. In Paradise Lost, the narrator’s method of employing epic structure and the framework of the story of the Fall, is much the same in its attempts to provide a context for the audience.
Although the attempts in providing contexts for their respective audiences do not address either John or the narrator’s education, another detail draws a parallel between the two and answers this question. Equivocating the method of narration between the two is sound being that both attempt to describe the infinite through the context of the finite. This establishes the transitory qualities of both tales, but does not relate to the transitional processes that both have undergone in their understanding. The beginning of the Book of Revelation states that John’s story is the reception of spiritual vision. Unlike the narrator of Paradise Lost, who calls to the muse to aid him/her in the telling of the tale, John is described simply as receiving the vision. The desire as to whether or not he wanted to see it is not concretely told. Being that this detail is not included, the argument that John has engaged in seeking out knowledge and understanding to avoid becoming a “heretic in the truth” may be called into question. In looking at Revelation 1:9, an answer is provided. The verse states, “I, John, both your brother and companion in the tribulation and kingdom and patience of Jesus Christ, was on the island that is called Patmos for the word of God and for the testimony of Jesus Christ” (NKJ). The detail is John’s location. He is on the Island of Patmos, which according to the works of Eusebius (among others), places him in exile due to the religious persecution that he was likely to suffer by remaining in Rome. Being in exile suggests that the things that John normally would have been doing probably have to be put on hold. In a new location, displaced because of his religious beliefs, it is likely that he is concerned with seeking out a way to further his understanding. Historically, John is writing Revelation shortly after the death of Jesus, to whom John was devoted. The situation lends itself as an opportune time to fully engage in the process of obtaining deeper understanding. If this is the case, then John’s writings form the reconciliation of his engaged study with the spiritual vision he receives.
Exile connects John to the process of searching for fuller understanding in which the narrator of Paradise Lost is engaged. John’s exile further connects him with Milton’s narrator not only in the process undertaken, but also in that the narrator is also in exile. Book III relates:
...but not to me returns
Day, or the sweet approach of Ev’n or Morn
Or sight of vernal bloom, or Summer’s Rose,
Or flocks, or herds, or human face divine;
But cloud instead, and ever-during dark
Surrounds me, from the cheerful ways of men
Cut off...(3:41-7)
Whether physical or metaphorical, the narrator’s description of his/her situation surely represents one of exile. The requests made to the muse illustrate the narrator’s willingness to be transformed. The calling that is described of the narrator suggests that the realization he/she has come to is that he/she cannot be removed from exile until there is someone with whom he/she can identify. Thus by telling the tale, the narrator will not only come to his/her own more fully realized sense about what the pursuit of further understanding has brought on, but may inspire another person to engage in a similar discourse or capture an audience that has underwent a similar process.
What further connects John and Milton’s narrator is the idea of divine revelation. Both instances exemplify an active engagement in increasing knowledge and understanding that results in the active seeking and possible fulfilment of receiving divine knowledge. John, though deceptively passive in his vision, is not really as passive as he may seem, as he describes himself actively seeking the spiritual in Revelations 4:1, “After these things I looked, and behold, a door standing open” (NKJ). John’s active seeking or “look(ing)” both in study during his exile and as he begins to receive divine visions exemplifies the process of transformation that occurs and how someone must actively seek it, thus preventing what he already knows from sickening “into a muddy pool of conformity and tradition”. The narrator of Paradise Lost, likewise seeks the spiritual, and as the allusions and apparatus of the poem exemplify, has also been engaged in intense study as well. The combination of both hard study the realization produced by it--that spiritual things must be sought as well—result to “Irradiate, there plant eyes, all mist from thence / Purge and disperse, that I may see and tell / Of things invisible to mortal sight” (1:52-4).
Concluding then, the narrator of Paradise Lost is a person who has been metaphorically and possibly physically exiled. The result of the exile is an engaged study of history, religion and spirituality that the narrator eventually concludes must be guided by a divine presence. In processing the exile and the body of knowledge both physical and spiritual that he/she has received, the narrator writes a poem in order to relate his/her experience and be reconciled once again to “the cheerful ways of men”.
Works Cited
Armitage, David, Himy, Armand, and Skinner, Quentin, eds. Milton and Republicanism. Cambridge University Press: New York, 1998. Print.
Herman, Peter C. Destabilizing Milton. Palgrave McMillan: New York, 2005. Print.
Himy, Armand. “Paradise Lost as a republican ‘tractus theologico-politicus’”, from Milton and Republicanism. Cambridge University Press: New York, 1998. Print.
Hughes, Merrit Y, ed. John Milton: Complete Poems and Major Prose. Hackett: Indianapolis, 2003. Print.
Labriola, Albert C. “Introduction: Postmodern Biographical Study of John Milton.” from: Milton Studies XXXVIII. John Milton: The Writer in His Works. University of Pittsburgh Press: Pittsburgh, 2000. Print.
Labriola, Albert C and Lieb, Michael, eds. Milton Studies XXXVIII. John Milton: The Writer in His Works. University of Pittsburgh Press: Pittsburgh, 2000. Print.
Martel, Yann. Life of Pi. Random House: Canada, 2001. Print.
Melbourne, Jane. “The Narrator as Chorus in Paradise Lost”. Studies in English Literature, 1500-1900. Vol. 33, No. 1. Rice University Press, 1993. Web.
Milton, John. Areopagitica. from John Milton: Complete Poems and Major Prose. Hackett: Indianapolis, 2003. Print.
Paradise Lost. from John Milton: Complete Poems and Major Prose. Hackett: Indianapolis, 2003. Print.
Paradise Regained. from John Milton: Complete Poems and Major Prose. Hackett: Indianapolis, 2003. Print.
Wittreich, Joseph. “’Reading’ Milton: The Death (and Survival) of the Author.” from Milton Studies XXXVIII. John Milton: The Writer in His Works. University of Pittsburgh Press: Pittsburgh, 2000. Print.